Spike Your Eggnog with these Michigan-Made Liquors

Get into the holiday spirit with our boozy pairings featuring Two James, Valentine, Detroit City Distillery, Rusted Crow, and Cabresto


Published:

Like Black Friday or ugly sweaters, eggnog is one of those things that’s synonymous with the holidays. With its silky texture and sweet and spicy flavors, this creamy beverage is prime for boozy pairings, sure to warm your chest even in the iciest of conditions. After a blind taste test and much deliberation, we have painstakingly ranked locally distilled liquors in search of the perfect complement to eggnog. Cheers!

Winner: Davy Jones’ Rum – Rusted Crow Distillery 

It’s no surprise that good rum is a natural pairing for ’nog. Our tasters noted the combo’s traditional taste, comparable to passed-down family recipes. Although Davy Jones isn’t spiced rum, its flavor brought out the warm flavor of the cinnamon, finished with a slightly sneaky and satisfying burn. 

 

Second Place: Railroad Gin, Detroit City Distillery 

This took us all by surprise. Combined with eggnog, the gin took on a sweet flavor similar to brandy. One tester noted it “tasted like Christmas,” but kept the integrity of the eggnog. “Very smooth,” another said, calling it the most “dangerously drinkable.” 

 

Third Place: Vodka, Valentine Distilling Co.  

Half of our panel couldn’t even taste the alcohol when mixed in. Still, for those looking for a boozy treat, this was polarizing, pulling both favorite and least favorite comments. If you’re looking for a spike without the burn, this is surely the choice for you.

 

Fourth Place: Grass Widow Bourbon, Two James Spirits 

A fraction of a point separated our third- and fourth-place winners. The strong rye flavor pulled mostly positive reviews, earning favor for spiciness and whiskey tones. Regular bourbon drinkers noted the combination’s smoothness; others were taken aback by the strong flavor.

 

Fifth Place: Ultra Silver Tequila, Cabresto

While its sweetness worked on some level, when combined with the syrupy eggnog, it became apparent why the liquor is best mixed with sour and acidic flavors. On its own? Yes. Paired with ’nog? Not so much.

Edit Module
Edit Module Edit ModuleShow Tags

Archive »Related Content

Birdie’s Something Chocolate Makes a Ganache With Panache

The local business is making sweet success out of a family recipe

Recipe: Fish Tacos with Cabbage and Jalapeño Slaw

Entertaining made easy with this favorite from London Chop House’s R.J. Scherer

Cocktail Recipe: Woodford Mint Julep

The Guilt-free Truth about Truffles

From ingredients to packaging, this sweet treat offers a healthy twist on snacking

City Bakery Finds a Home Inside the Fisher Building

Detroit gets a taste of New York with the bakery's first Midwest expansion
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Most Popular

  1. 7 Michigan Breweries Worth a Trip
    Check out these must-visit locations during your summer travels
  2. To Market, to Market
    Michigan Wine & Cider Festival at Eastern Market May 24
  3. Hour Media’s Real Estate All-Star Party 2017
    Hour Media's Real Estate All-Stars celebrated at the fourth annual Real Estate All-Star Party...
  4. Your Guide to Michigan’s Odd and Unusual Festivals
    We rounded up some of the state’s most niche events, celebrating everything from fishflies to...
  5. Meet the Southwest Detroit Pizzeria Serving Sospeso
    PizzaPlex in southwest Detroit is challenging what it means to be a new business on the block
  6. An Hour With... Candice S. Miller
    Macomb County Public Works Commissioner
  7. Dry Times: Looking Back 100 Years After Prohibition
    A century ago, Detroit became the first city in the nation to prohibit alcohol
  8. ‘Grazie Mille’ For the Memories
    Adventures abound in Italy with Michigan winemaker, grape growers
  9. The Gentleman’s Guide to Style
    From grooming to shopping, a comprehensive directory for stylish men in metro Detroit
  10. Motherhood in Metro Detroit
    From pre-pregnancy thoughts to developing unconditional love, several local women give a glimpse...