What You Need to Know About Oil and Gas Drilling in the Suburbs

Energy companies are staking out new territory in metro Detroit


Published:

In 2015, Traverse City-based Jordan Development Co. approached the leadership of Word of Faith International Christian Center in Southfield with a proposition — but whether said proposition was promising or alarming depends on whom you ask.

Word of Faith church is located on a sprawling 100-plus-acre property on the corner of Nine Mile and Evergreen roads, and Jordan Development’s preliminary tests revealed oil might be present there. The exploration and development company applied for a permit to drill a test well to confirm; if the site proved profitable, the church would receive royalties.

Once the project was announced, though, Southfield residents, government officials, and politicians launched massive protests, some of which continued into the fall of 2017. The church is in a heavily wooded suburban neighborhood; there’s a public park right across the street. While the test well was being constructed in late 2016, nearby residents complained of noise, odor, and light pollution after dark. At one point flames were visible through the tree line — the result of burning natural gas deposits found while drilling.

The City of Southfield attempted to prevent the test well’s construction in March 2016, but the lawsuit was ultimately thrown out in Oakland County’s Circuit Court. The city appealed, but the case was dismissed again in November 2017. The reason? Jordan Development had actually abandoned the well six months earlier, after determining the site wasn’t commercially viable — rendering the issue moot.

So, if the neighborhood had already been spared, why did the city continue to appeal? Both Mayor Kenson Siver and Susan Ward-Witkowski, the city’s attorney, say the legal battle has never been about opposing drilling entirely; it’s about fighting for a municipality’s right to determine where the drilling can take place. But therein lies the issue: Under state law, communities don’t actually have much of a say. The Michigan Department of Environmental Quality — specifically, its Oil, Gas, and Minerals Division — is responsible for approving permits for wells. Residents and local governments can complain all they want, but if the state says development can continue, it will. In fact, if an applicant meets all requirements — a key one being that wells must be drilled at least 450 feet from nearby homes — the permit must be issued. Drilling can’t be denied simply because of public criticism, or the state could be sued.

For high-risk projects, the MDEQ can request special conditions, and if the company doesn’t or can’t comply, it might be forced to abandon a project. In Southfield, there were 20-plus special conditions tacked on to account for the population density. But there are no laws that outright prohibit oil and gas exploration in residential neighborhoods.

Jack Lanigan, the senior geologist for the OGMD’s Southeast Michigan District Office, oversaw the Word of Faith project. He empathizes with people who take the “not-in-my-backyard” approach, but he says the system works like it does for a reason. As an example, he offers a hypothetical case of an operator trying to extract oil along Eight Mile Road, where Southfield borders Detroit. If every city had its own regulations, he says, and there was a dispute over jurisdiction, it would be a nightmare. “You can’t move minerals. They occur where they do.”

Disputes like these over oil wells aren’t all that common; oil exploration has actually been declining statewide for more than a decade. But today’s boom in natural gas exploration could present similar challenges. In 2017, DTE Energy committed to reducing its carbon emissions by 80 percent and closing all its coal plants by 2050. That means relying more heavily on natural gas, which likely means pipelines will creep closer and closer to high-density populations.

Unlike oil wells, interstate pipelines are not required to have uniform setbacks from residential properties. In addition, states are involved in regulation to some degree, but the final approval rests with the federal government.

Since 2014, activists in Washtenaw, Monroe, Livingston, and Lenawee counties have been fighting the arrival of the Nexus and ET Rover natural gas pipelines. (DTE Energy is a part-owner of Nexus.) Some townships even passed resolutions to try to prohibit Nexus, but the pipeline was approved by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission in August 2017. ET Rover was approved February 2017.

Oday Salim, executive director and managing attorney at Great Lakes Environmental Law Center, says the takeaway is that residents who are concerned about these issues need to petition a much higher power. Generally, that would mean lobbying state or federal representatives instead of local ones. He points to the infamous Keystone XL pipeline as a case study on how targeted activism can work — and fail. The Obama administration rejected the expansion of Keystone in part due to citizen protests; President Donald Trump, however, approved it in March 2017.

Salim also stresses residents should manage their expectations: Pressuring the federal government to abandon or deny a fossil fuel project is unlikely, but altering its course — that may be doable.

Bottom line: Voting for representatives at both the state and federal levels who prioritize these issues will remain key — as will plenty of patience.

 

Edit Module
Edit Module

Hour Detroit Magazine

Edit ModuleShow Tags

Archive »Related Content

An Hour With ... Richard Broder

Owner and CEO, Broder & Sachse Real Estate Inc.

The Way it Was

Packard Motor Car Company, 1912

Introducing the Nordin Brothers: The Duo Behind the Detroit Design Center

You may not know their names, but chances are, you've seen their art

Meet the Makers: Pingree Detroit

The brand is employing veterans to craft upcycled leather totes and journals

There's No Stopping Jill Jack

The Award-winning Detroit musician releases her 12th album — and starts a new artist development company
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Most Popular

  1. Why Abdul El-Sayed's Run for Governor Is for Real
    Can a political rookie from Michigan become America's first Muslim governor?
  2. Female Entrepreneurs Are Staking Their Claim in Detroit
    These three women-owned businesses are unstacking the deck
  3. Michigan’s Craft Distilleries Are Setting Their Sights on Bourbon
    Proof that the best things require patience
  4. Inside the Resurrected Takoi
    The restaurant has survived arson and controversy to claim a top spot in Detroit's culinary scene
  5. The Era of Autonomous Vehicles May Be Here Sooner than Expected
    What does that mean for Detroit's legacy automakers?
  6. Introducing the Nordin Brothers: The Duo Behind the Detroit Design Center
    You may not know their names, but chances are, you've seen their art
  7. The Faces of Michigan Wine: Josh Morgan
    To say that 2017 was a pivotal year for Josh Morgan would be putting it mildly.
  8. Meet the Makers: Pingree Detroit
    The brand is employing veterans to craft upcycled leather totes and journals
  9. It's Game On for Detroit's 'Bar Arcade' Scene
    M-Brew, Pop + Offworld, and Ready Player One pair microbrews with retro video games
  10. What You Need to Know About Oil and Gas Drilling in the Suburbs
    Energy companies are staking out new territory in metro Detroit