Enduring Culture

For Native Americans, Thanksgiving can be tinged with sorrow



The fourth Thursday of November is a welcome holiday, a ritual set aside for giving thanks — for turkey, football, a long weekend, or early-bird shopping. What began centuries ago as a celebration of a bountiful harvest holds a different meaning for various cultural groups — particularly for descendants of America’s indigenous people.

“Most people aren’t really interested in the Wampanoag,” Margaret Noori says, referring to one of the tribes that shared the “first” Thanksgiving feast with the Pilgrims of Plymouth Rock in 1621.

Noori, a lecturer in the University of Michigan’s Native American Studies Program, is of Ojibwa descent and an expert on the Anishinaabemowin language of Great Lakes-region tribes. “We really try to get students and teachers to think about that early dinner as a metaphor for the cultures being together with one another on the continent,” Noori says.

Others observe the day through a lens of sorrow. This Thanksgiving marks the 40th anniversary of the National Day of Mourning, which began as a Native American protest near Plymouth Rock. “It’s a statement,” says Kay McGowan, who is of Mississippi Chocktaw and Cherokee heritage and teaches native studies at Eastern Michigan University. “It’s a mechanism for raising awareness.”

McGowan and Noori agree that fighting for indigenous causes is an uphill battle. “Because we’re so small in number, we have to pick our poison,” McGowan says.

Native American numbers in Michigan are most concentrated in Wayne County, where they experience the greatest rate of joblessness, McGowan says.

Such challenges make it important to remember that Thanksgiving is about more than turkey and pie. “It’s nice that we have a positive holiday, and it gives some indigenous awareness,” Noori says.

In October, Noori was one of four U-M professors who spoke about native food and culture at the second annual Native American Dinner at Zingerman’s Roadhouse in Ann Arbor. The menu highlighted indigenous Great Lakes fare, such as hominy, rabbit succotash, roast duck, and frybreads.

“This is something we want to be doing every year, 10, 20 years from now, and really build up … people’s awareness of, and appreciation for, the history of where we’re living and for traditions that are still very much alive today,” says Ari Weinzweig, Zingerman’s co-founder.

And though Zingerman’s annual feast is not indicative of the type of food at that “first” Thanksgiving, which likely relied heavily on berries, nuts, and venison, keeping traditions alive is critical.

“Typically, native participation in Thanksgiving is thought of as this distant moment in time,” Noori says. But Native Americans have not gone away. There are more than 500 sovereign Native American nations within the United States, and thousands still speak the language of Noori and McGowan’s ancestors — an enduring culture worthy of thanks.

Archive »Related Content

Good Reads

Editor Steve Wilke sums up some of his favorite books of the month.

Bringing the Heat

Photo exhibit puts the focus on fire performers.

Web Exclusive: Interview with Apolis, a brand featured at Willys Detroit

Tiger Tales

Wives reflect on lives spent with baseball icons.

Joining the Table

A newcomer’s edible introduction to Detroit reveals an idiosyncratic and unpretentious restaurant scene

Most Popular

  1. Butchers, Bakers, & Candy Makers
    Locals aim for a slice of the food industry pie
  2. A Taste for Travel
    Culinary tourists and locals are finding a wealth of fine dining around Traverse City
  3. Standing the Heat
    In a world of culinary stars inspired by Julia Child, where are all the female executive chefs?
  4. So You Wanna Be A Chef (Or Just Cook Like One)
    Local culinary classes range from making doughnuts to earning degrees.
  5. Fresh Fare
    Treetops Resort's Farm2Fork events tap the bounty of local producers.
  6. Better When Basted
    Big Rock's Matthew Fitchett gives lamb a seared spin.
  7. The Way It Was - State Fairs
  8. Rockford Brewing Company Brewery Profile
    Embracing the outdoors and the creative spirit, Rockford Brewing Company works to promote a...