Essay: Detroit Can Beat the Gentrification Game

It won’t be easy, but the city can be a national model for inclusive economic redevelopment


Published:

New money comes in; old people move out. It’s the ebb and flow of development. Brooklyn, San Francisco, Atlanta, and now, finally, Detroit.

The allure of suburban cul-de-sacs is waning as millennials yearn for the diversity and culture of dense urban cores. 

Now, less encumbered by the stigma of industry, racial tension, or anti-regionalism, Detroit has become a target for redevelopment and fresh energy. With that interest comes the specter of gentrification. It’s on the tips of every tongue, from neighborhood activists to developers. Some stoke fire-and-brimstone scenarios; others try to assuage fears by pointing to benefits of the changing economic landscape. 

“Sure,” they say. “With those changes come a few casualties. Senior citizen housing, low-income families, and, of course, homeless people have to go. But that’s for the greater good, right?”

Maybe not.

For years organizations, block clubs, and committees have waged hyper-localized campaigns to make their communities livable and desirable. Whether it’s community organizations like Grandmont Rosedale Development Corp. or the well-funded and powerful — some might say too powerful — Midtown Detroit Inc., many have tried to initiate economic corridors of opportunity. The Downtown Detroit Partnership worked for years, in different incarnations, to make “Financial District” more than a moniker. 

Nothing kicked the change engine into overdrive quite like Dan Gilbert’s investing in 90 buildings and the PR engine his organization used to elevate Detroit’s “comeback” story. Chicken-and-egg “do we need people or jobs first?” questions seemed gone in one fell swoop. He brought in higher-paying jobs, subsidized workers’ living options, and programmed activities to create the skeleton of a hip, trendy city.

Others followed suit. New companies, unique bars, restaurants, and overpriced, nonrenovated lofts began to hit the market. Long-vacant buildings became $100,000-plus industrial-styled “hipster” pads.

Between 2011 and 2016, rent prices downtown and Midtown have gone from an average of the mid-$700s to over $1,100 — and climbing. This despite the city’s poverty rate of nearly 40 percent. 

In the past five years, even the first waves of “new Detroiters” capitalizing on low prices and inspiring urban decay have been priced out of their artist bunkers to make way for a new class of imports. In 2014 CNN reported some stories of Detroit displacement. One was a young designer and another a 30-year, long-term resident of her building, which is being renovated and re-marketed. 

The combination of corporate subsidies and landlords wanting more from their properties has created a perfect storm. But Detroit’s housing story is much more complicated. As soon as you leave the ivory walls of “Greater Downtown,” home prices drop precipitously. In far-flung corners of the city, you find rentals in the $400s. Beautiful brick houses and multi-family units are sold for mere thousands. 

"Detroit grew as a flat sprawl instead of upward towers. That gives us a unique opportunity to beat gentrification here."

Widespread blight and higher crime rates have cratered the market. But more so, most property owners are simply catering to the market that they have — the low income.

Detroit has been victim to population drain for decades, often attributed to “white flight” and 1967’s civil unrest. Deeper research points to families following jobs as auto companies fled to the suburbs looking for land to expand. Some 50 years of misinformation, regional tension, and economic decline added up to make us the only city in America to peak well over, then fall below, 1 million residents. 

This city grew as a unique flat sprawl instead of upward towers. Now, we have more abandoned homes than any city. Blight might be the only thing with more screen time than gentrification these days. 

But that sprawl gives Detroit a unique opportunity where other places have failed. We could beat gentrification here. 

You can see the wheels starting to turn. Witness the Detroit Land Bank Authority’s efforts to streamline the process of auctioning homes. The Stay Midtown program is finally offering subsidies to longtime residents of redeveloping neighborhoods. 

High entry barriers to “the 7.2” — the rebranded imprint marketing downtown and Midtown without the stigma of the “other Detroit” — has forced development to leak into other neighborhoods. 

North End, West Village, and Jefferson/Chalmers benefit by being near, but not inside, those districts. The Detroit Economic Growth Corp. is creating more small business density in those neighborhoods with organizations like Motor City Match. Unique programs like NEIdeas (New Economy Initiative) fund entrepreneurs to create new narratives of how communities can support themselves. Work by Hajj Flemings’ Rebrand Detroit and David Alade’s Century Partners show how you can develop equity with a neighborhood, not just around it.

Even longstanding business chambers that once did everything in their power to position southeast Michigan as “despite Detroit” are starting to double down on Detroit. Conversations about neighborhood and workforce development are raised in their hallowed halls and economic forums.

Clearly, there’s more work to do. As a guy who once wrote an article called, “Why I Hate Detroit,” I have plenty of complaints. But I truly believe we can become the national model for inclusive economic redevelopment — if we seize this moment. If we zero in on outcomes, we can shift our focus — not just preservation of historic homes and neighborhood names, but preservation of longtime Detroiters: the core and heartbeat that kept Detroit afloat for years.

Partnership with the energy of a shifting demographic and, finally, the institutional support we’ve needed all along could change the gentrification game. 

With 142 square miles, there should be more than enough Detroit to go around. Let’s make sure we grow in a way that’s healthy and provides opportunity for everyone. This is a historical moment for our city. “How we beat gentrification” is the story I want to tell my kids about. 

Edit Module
Edit Module Edit ModuleShow Tags

Archive »Related Content

Here's Why Petoskey’s Bay View Resort Is Under a Magnifying Glass

The history, facts, and recent allegations against the National Landmark

Expand Your Personal Library with These 6 Titles

New and notable reads to satisfy your inner bookworm

Add These 6 Titles to Your Summer Reading List

New and notable reads to enjoy through the season

A Look Inside Bob’s Jukebox Emporium

Morningside resident Bob Welke is the man to call for vintage music machine repairs, restorations, and more

Checking in With Electric Six

With more than 20 years in the business and 14 albums under their collective belts, a cult-favorite band rocks on
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Most Popular

  1. Review: Testa Barra Wows with Contemporary Dishes
    The Macomb Township restaurant serves Italian fare that is on par with the surging Detroit food...
  2. Michigan-Made, Mother Nature-Approved Tools for Your Kitchen
    Ditch disposables and opt for reusable products
  3. Exploring Metro Detroit’s Tiki Trend
    Mutiny Bar and Lost River serve up island vacations with every drink
  4. A Deeper Look into the Racial and Ethnic Tensions Dividing Metro Detroit
    From the city to the suburbs, existing segregation could be hindering the region’s progress
  5. Every Day is Throwback Thursday at This Roseville Steakhouse
    Mr. Paul's Chophouse has remained consistently delicious for more than 50 years
  6. A Look at the Inexplicable Exclusion of Detroit Tigers’ Lou Whitaker from the Baseball Hall of Fame
    Writer Michael Betzhold investigates the Major League slip-up
  7. 3 Eateries that Focus on People, Profit, and the Planet
    These triple bottom line businesses are part of Detroit’s FoodLab organization
  8. Q&A: Nancy Barr, Curator of Photography at the Detroit Institute of Arts
    Plus, information about the DIA’s upcoming exhibit, Lost & Found
  9. This Vegan Catering Company Celebrates the ‘Natural Beauty of Food’
    Plus, tips on how to create your own photo-worthy grazing board
  10. Meet the Makers: Salt Textile Studios
    This textile maker wants her creations to be unique to ‘here’