Book Review: ‘The Stranger in the Lifeboat’ By Mitch Albom

Detroit’s top-selling writer cranks out another overwrought but pleasing spiritual page-turner
mitch albom the stranger in the lifeboat
‘he Stranger in the Lifeboat image courtesy of HarperCollins

The COVID-19 pandemic changed everything, but it also reinforced this universal truth: Things get real pretty quickly when people are trapped in a confined space for a sustained period. 

Yes, when there’s no escape hatch and conflicts arise, those involved must confront each other or do something drastic — which results in high drama, the likes of which anchor most reality television and no small number of plays, films, and other works of fiction. 

Mitch Albom’s newest novel, The Stranger in the Lifeboat, fits neatly into this tradition, albeit with a heavy spiritual bent. 

As the book starts, 10 people find themselves adrift in a lifeboat during a storm, having survived a megayacht’s mysterious explosion. Some are workers on the boat, including our narrator, Benji; some are among the famous figures who’ve been gathered for a kind of global trailblazer summit; and one is the billionaire who planned the event and owned the yacht, Jason Lambert.

But there are also two passengers pulled aboard whom no one recognizes: a girl who doesn’t speak and a strangely uninjured young man whose first words are “I am the Lord.”

We learn about all the lifeboat passengers, as well as what happens to them, by way of a notebook Benji writes in. That notebook also serves as the conduit for the novel’s other storyline, in which a Caribbean police inspector is called out, a year after the yacht explosion and the passengers’ disappearance, to see what remains of a lifeboat washed up on his shores. 

Like the ocean waves that propel the lifeboat hither and yon, Stranger has an undeniable momentum. The novel’s claustrophobic, high-stakes setup keeps the pages turning, as does its structure, with short, digestible chapters that shift around in time and perspective.

Still, Albom’s prose is sometimes self-consciously labored. On the very first page, in fact, we’re told, with regard to the character of “the Lord,” that “his eyes were pale blue, the color you imagine the ocean to be when you dream of a tropical vacation.” This may, of course, be Albom intentionally painting Benji as an unimaginative and trite writer, but moments like this nonetheless tripped me up every time.

And while Benji’s journaling provides a convenient means of telling the story of those in the lifeboat — while also connecting it to the police inspector — the notebook is a highly problematic narrative device. Benji addresses his writings, from the start, to his lost love: “I am writing to you in the pages of this notebook, Annabelle, in hopes you might somehow read them after I am gone. I need to tell you something, and I need to tell the world as well.”

While I could maybe, possibly believe that a survivor in this situation would address his writings to his wife, I couldn’t get past the manner in which Benji relays his tale: with full conversations of dialogue, featuring multiple voices; with flashbacks and explanations that wouldn’t be necessary if his wife were really the intended reader; and with awkward moments like this, when Benji finds a fellow lifeboat passenger’s suicide note among his scribbles: “I closed the notebook and dropped my head. I cried so hard my chest hurt, but my eyes stayed dry as dust.”

Would you write in a journal about a moment when you closed the journal? Probably not. And this precisely elucidates the daunting challenge of using this “notebook” approach. If you’re going to write first-person sections of a novel and say they’re a character’s journal, the sections must feel genuine and true to that context. In Stranger, they don’t.

But Albom, the Detroit Free Press sportswriter who has become our city’s most famous and successful living author of both fiction and nonfiction, knows what he’s doing. His fans flock to his work for its sadness-tinged-with-hope vibe and spiritual uplift, and they’ll be more than satisfied with Stranger. There are twists and surprises as well as, unsurprisingly, a heartwarming conclusion.

For those less smitten by Albom, your reception will depend on your views about religious faith. Let’s just say that, if you’re moved by this concluding paragraph, you’ll love the rest of Stranger: “In the end, there is the sea and the land and the news that happens between them. To spread that news, we tell each other stories. Sometimes the stories are about survival. And sometimes those stories, like the presence of the Lord, are hard to believe. Unless believing is what makes them true.”

This story is featured in the December 2021 issue of Hour Detroit magazine. Read more stories in our digital edition.